Expert Diesel Knowledge. Always Free.
Commercial vehicle safety inspectors examining a semi-trailer's brake components, air lines, and wheel assemblies during a roadside inspection, illustrating CVSA Brake Safety Week enforcement.

Brake Safety Week Results: What Inspectors Keep Finding

By Michael Nielsen, Publisher | 15+ Years in Diesel Repair & Fleet Operations

Last Updated: November 2026

⏱ Estimated reading time: 13 minutes

Brake safety week results from CVSA's 2026 campaign show 15.3 percent of 15,528 inspected commercial vehicles were placed out of service for brake-related violations. The 2,369 vehicles were inspected August 23-29 across 51 jurisdictions. Defective-brake counts, hoses and tubing, and drums and rotors led the findings, and the rate sits above every other Brake Safety Week rate on CVSA's results page since 2016.

This Heavy Duty Journal guide reads the 2026 brake safety week results against 2025 and earlier years, explains what each violation category means for a shop and lists what to check before the next inspection. It builds on HDJ's CVSA brake inspection standards guide and DOT brake inspection checklist.

Key Takeaways

  • 0115.3% brake out-of-service rate. 2,369 of 15,528 vehicles inspected in 2026 were placed out of service for brake violations.
  • 02The 20% rule led again. 1,176 vehicles were cited under the 20% defective brake criterion, about half of the out-of-service total.
  • 03Hoses and tubing doubled. Reported hose and tubing violations rose from 306 in 2025 to 600 in 2026.
  • 04Drums and rotors were the focus. 141 violations led to 64 vehicles out of service; air disc rotors accounted for 97.
  • 05Brake testers failed 4.41%. 29 of 657 vehicles tested on performance-based brake testers missed the 43.5% minimum.
  • 06Next campaign: April 18-24, 2027. Both FleetOwner and CCJ report the 2027 dates.

01

What the 2026 Brake Safety Week Results Show

Brake Safety Week is CVSA's annual seven-day inspection and compliance campaign, run by inspectors in the United States, Canada and Mexico. The 2026 brake safety week results, reported by FleetOwner on November 10 and CCJ on November 11, 2026, counted 15,528 inspections and 2,369 vehicles with brake-related out-of-service violations. That leaves 13,159 vehicles, or 84.7 percent, with no brake-related out-of-service violation.

The campaign ran August 23-29, 2026, and 14,150 of the inspections, 91 percent, were North American Standard Level I inspections. CVSA publishes its own release at CVSA's 2026 campaign release page. HDJ could not open that page from its research tools, so the 2026 figures here come from FleetOwner and CCJ, which agree with each other on every number HDJ compared.

The headline gap is small. In 2025, CVSA reported 15.1 percent of 15,175 inspected vehicles out of service (CVSA's 2025 campaign release). The 2026 figure is 0.2 points higher, which is within the range a shift in which vehicles got inspected could explain. The bigger signal is that the rate has stayed high for two years running.

02

Results by Country

Brake enforcement results differ by country, and Canada again posted the highest out-of-service rate. The U.S. accounted for 14,165 of the 15,528 inspections, Canada for 1,306 and Mexico for 57. Mexico's sample is too small to compare, with 3 out-of-service vehicles out of 57 inspected.

Exhibit 1. 2026 Brake Safety Week by country
CountryInspectionsBrake out of serviceRate
United States14,1652,13415.1%
Canada1,30623217.8%
Mexico5735.3%
North America15,5282,36915.3%

Canada's rate was 17.8 percent in both 2026 and 2025, according to CVSA's 2025 release and the 2026 coverage. The U.S. rate moved from 14.9 percent in 2025 to 15.1 percent in 2026. Heavy Duty Journal reads the U.S. number as the one most fleets should plan around, because it covers 91 percent of the inspections.

03

Why Vehicles Were Placed Out of Service

The 20 percent defective brake criterion was again the most common reason for an out-of-service brake order. In 2026, 1,176 vehicles were placed out of service under it, which CCJ calculated as 49.6 percent of the out-of-service total. Brake hoses and tubing came next with 600 violations, then air loss rate with 145 and steering axle conditions with 211.

Exhibit 2. Brake-related out-of-service reasons, 2026 compared with 2025
Category20262025Change
20% defective brakes1,1761,199Down 23
Brake hoses and tubing600306Up 294
Air loss rate145100Up 45
Steering axle (2026: 92 linings, 119 other)211199Up 12
Other brake violations759375Up 384

Read Exhibit 2 with care. FleetOwner and CCJ list most categories as violation counts, while the 20 percent figure and the total are vehicle counts, and one vehicle can carry several violations. The categories therefore cannot be added up to 2,369. HDJ combined the two 2026 steering axle lines (92 plus 119) to match the single 2025 line.

Hoses and tubing deserve a closer look. A count that doubled in one year suggests inspectors found more chafed, cracked or leaking lines, but HDJ cannot tell from the sources whether the cause is aging equipment, deferred maintenance or a change in how violations were recorded. HDJ's air brake troubleshooting guide and trailer brake troubleshooting guide cover how to find leaks and damaged lines before an inspector does.

04

Drum and Rotor Findings

Drums and rotors were the 2026 focus area, and they produced 141 violations and 64 vehicles out of service. In 2025 the same focus area produced 113 violations and 39 vehicles. Rotor and drum condition is where air disc brakes showed the most trouble: 97 of the 2026 violations were on air disc systems, against 36 on S-cam and 8 on hydraulic brakes.

Exhibit 3. Drum and rotor violations by brake type
Brake type20262025
Air disc9772
S-cam3632
Hydraulic89
Total violations141113
Vehicles out of service6439

CVSA's 2025 release breaks the air disc findings into 50 rusted rotors and 22 broken rotors, with 32 broken drums on S-cam brakes. HDJ did not find the same breakdown for 2026 in FleetOwner or CCJ. The Brake Safety Day coverage from The BRAKE Report names rusted air disc rotors as the most common drum and rotor finding that day.

The practical lesson is for fleets moving to air disc brakes. Disc rotors hide corrosion at the edge and in the vanes, and a rusted or cracked rotor is a roadside violation, not a wear item to carry to the next service. HDJ's disc brakes versus drum brakes comparison covers the trade-offs, and 49 CFR 393.47(g) says drums and rotors must not be thinner than the manufacturer's limit (49 CFR 393.47, Cornell Law School).

05

Performance-Based Brake Testers

Performance-based brake testers, or PBBTs, measure braking force on a rolling-road machine instead of relying on a visual check. In 2026, 12 U.S. jurisdictions ran 657 inspections with PBBTs, and 29 vehicles, 4.41 percent, failed the 43.5 percent minimum braking efficiency and were placed out of service. A passing visual inspection does not guarantee a passing tester result.

In 2025, 15 states ran 528 PBBT inspections, and 25 vehicles, 4.7 percent, failed the same 43.5 percent minimum. The failure rate fell slightly in 2026, from 4.7 percent to 4.41 percent. HDJ does not draw a trend from that, because fewer jurisdictions took part and the vehicle mix is unknown.

Brake Safety and Compliance Updates

Get weekly updates on brake safety, CVSA enforcement and fleet compliance from Heavy Duty Journal, delivered to your inbox.

Testers matter because they catch problems an inspector cannot see: a brake that is within lining limits but is not producing force. Contamination, glazed linings, a seized cam or a mismatched component can all pass a walk-around. A fleet with access to a tester can use it as a pre-inspection check, and HDJ's S-cam brake adjustment guide covers the adjustment side.

06

Brake Safety Week Results Year by Year

The brake out-of-service rate has moved up since 2021, according to CVSA's results page. The 2026 rate of 15.3 percent is higher than any Brake Safety Week rate listed on that page for 2016 through 2025, including 14.1 percent in 2018, and 2019 works out to about 13.5 percent from the page's counts (CVSA brake safety campaign results). The number of inspections is a different story, falling from more than 38,000 in 2022 to about 15,000.

Exhibit 4. Brake Safety Week out-of-service rates, 2020 to 2026
YearVehicles inspectedBrake out of serviceSource
202043,56512%CVSA
202135,76412%CVSA
202238,11713.3%CVSA
202318,875About 12.6%CVSA (87.4% had none)
202416,725About 13%CVSA (about 87% had none)
202515,17515.1%CVSA
202615,52815.3%FleetOwner, CCJ

Two cautions apply. A rate for a week of targeted roadside inspections is not a fleet-wide defect rate, and HDJ did not find a CVSA statement on how vehicles are selected. Also, the 2023 and 2024 rates in Exhibit 4 are HDJ's subtraction from CVSA's "no brake-related out-of-service" shares, so they are approximate.

Why the rate rose is not answered in the sources HDJ read. Fewer inspections could mean more selective ones, aging equipment and deferred spending could play a part, and focus areas change every year. Heavy Duty Journal treats the pattern as a reason to inspect brakes on a fixed schedule instead of waiting for the announced week.

07

What Brake Safety Day Added

Brake Safety Day is CVSA's unannounced one-day brake enforcement event, and the 2026 edition on April 14 produced a worse result than the announced week. According to The BRAKE Report and CVSA's results page, 4,021 vehicles were inspected in 47 jurisdictions and 574, or 14.3 percent, were restricted from travel. In 2025, the Brake Safety Day figure was 8.7 percent of 4,569 vehicles.

The 2026 Brake Safety Day drum and rotor findings were 43 violations and 21 out-of-service vehicles, and performance-based brake testers failed 26 of 349 vehicles, or 7.45 percent. The 574 figure came from CVSA's page. The remaining Brake Safety Day details come from The BRAKE Report, which HDJ names but does not link.

15.3%

brake-related out-of-service rate in the 2026 campaign: 2,369 of 15,528 vehicles inspected (FleetOwner and CCJ, November 2026).

Editorial Insight

The HDJ Perspective

According to Heavy Duty Journal, the number that hurts a fleet is not the average brake, it is the worst few on the truck. In HDJ's field experience across 15+ years of coverage, trucks fail on one neglected axle, one cracked hose or one rusted rotor, so shops that rank the worst brake on every unit tend to clear inspections more often than shops that only measure averages.

08

How Inspectors Judge Brakes

Inspectors place a vehicle out of service when brake defects reach the limit in CVSA's out-of-service criteria. CCJ's summary of those criteria says a vehicle or combination is out of service if 20 percent or more of its service brakes have a listed defect, and that a steering axle brake with any listed defect is defective. HDJ read that summary, not the current criteria book, so check the current edition.

The underlying federal rules are in 49 CFR Part 393 and Part 396. Section 393.47 sets lining and pad minimums and pushrod stroke limits, and section 396.3 requires parts and accessories to be in safe and proper operating condition at all times and requires a carrier to keep inspection, repair and maintenance records for each vehicle for 30 consecutive days (49 CFR 396.3, Cornell Law School).

Exhibit 5. Selected lining and pad minimums in 49 CFR 393.47(d)
BrakeMinimumNote
Air drum, non-steering axle6.4 mm (1/4 in.)Measured at the shoe center
Air disc, non-steering axle3.2 mm (1/8 in.)Pad thickness
Air drum, steering axle, continuous strip4.8 mm (3/16 in.)Two-pad shoe: 6.4 mm
Air disc, steering axle3.2 mm (1/8 in.)Pad thickness
Drums and rotorsManufacturer limitSection 393.47(g)

These are the figures HDJ read on Cornell Law School's copy of the regulation as of November 2026. HDJ could not open the eCFR, so confirm them there before using them in a policy. Pushrod stroke limits are in 393.47(e) and depend on the actuator type, so use the table for the specific chamber on the truck.

09

A Fleet Brake Prep Checklist

A brake prep routine should cover the categories that dominated the 2026 brake safety week results: defective brakes, lines and hoses, air loss, steering axle linings and drums or rotors. The list below is HDJ's practical order, not a CVSA or FMCSA procedure, and it works as a quick check before any scheduled inspection week.

Brake checks to run before the next inspection

  • Count defective brakes per unit. Flag any unit near the 20 percent limit and fix the worst axle first.
  • Inspect every hose and line. Look for chafing, cracks, kinks and leaks, especially at brackets and flex points.
  • Run an air loss test. Check leakage rates and listen at chambers and fittings.
  • Measure steering axle linings. Steering axles have tighter standards, and any listed defect there counts.
  • Inspect rotors and drums. Check for rust, cracks, wear limits and metal-to-metal contact.
  • Keep the records. Section 396.3 expects a schedule and an inspection and repair history for each unit.

Pre-trip and post-trip inspections catch many of these before a roadside stop. Drivers can spot hose damage, audible leaks and out-of-adjustment pushrods, and the shop can handle the measurements. Fleets that track brake violations by unit and by driver can tie the results to their CSA score guide, where brake violations affect vehicle maintenance data.

Key Recommendation

Rank every unit by its single worst brake, fix hoses, rotors and steering axle linings first, and test air loss before the next inspection week, not after it.

Free Instant PDF Download

Free Diesel Maintenance Checklist

Get HDJ's free, field-tested diesel maintenance checklist delivered instantly to your inbox — print it, laminate it, keep it in the shop.

Instant PDF • 100% Free • No Spam

Free Diesel Maintenance Checklist download for heavy-duty truck maintenance

10

What HDJ Could Not Confirm

HDJ could not open CVSA's own 2026 Brake Safety Week release, so every 2026 figure in this guide comes from FleetOwner and CCJ. FleetOwner says its article was created with generative AI tools and edited by its content team, and CCJ's headline says "2,300 trucks" while its body says 2,369. HDJ used the body figure, which matches FleetOwner.

HDJ also could not confirm the reason for the rise in hose and tubing violations, how CVSA selects vehicles, or whether the 2025 and 2026 category definitions match exactly. As of November 2026, CVSA's campaign results page lists the Brake Safety Day result for 2026 but not the Brake Safety Week result, so the 2026 week is not yet in that multi-year table.

The 20 percent criterion is described from CCJ's summary of the out-of-service criteria, which HDJ could not match to the current CVSA book, and 393.47 is described from Cornell's copy. Heavy Duty Journal did not test any brake or tester. Michael Nielsen and the HDJ team will update the guide at heavydutyjournal.com when CVSA posts the full 2026 data.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the 2026 Brake Safety Week results?

CVSA inspectors checked 15,528 commercial vehicles August 23-29, 2026, and placed 2,369, or 15.3 percent, out of service for brake-related violations. The U.S. rate was 15.1 percent, Canada's was 17.8 percent and Mexico's was 5.3 percent. The figures come from FleetOwner and CCJ coverage.

When is the next Brake Safety Week?

FleetOwner and CCJ report that the next Brake Safety Week is April 18-24, 2027. CVSA held the 2026 campaign August 23-29. CVSA also runs an unannounced Brake Safety Day each year, which fleets cannot plan around, so brakes should be inspection-ready all year.

What is the most common brake out-of-service violation?

The 20 percent defective brake criterion was the most common in both 2025 and 2026. In 2026, 1,176 vehicles were placed out of service under it, about half of the 2,369 brake out-of-service vehicles. Brake hoses and tubing came second with 600 violations.

What is the 20 percent brake rule?

CCJ's summary of CVSA's out-of-service criteria says a vehicle or combination is out of service when 20 percent or more of its service brakes have a listed defect. A steering axle brake with any listed defect counts as defective. Check the current CVSA criteria edition for exact counts.

What was the focus area in 2026?

Drums and rotors. The 2026 campaign found 141 drum and rotor violations and placed 64 vehicles out of service: 97 violations on air disc brakes, 36 on S-cam brakes and 8 on hydraulic brakes. In 2025 the same focus area produced 113 violations and 39 vehicles.

Is the brake out-of-service rate getting worse?

CVSA's results page shows Brake Safety Week rates of 12 to 13.3 percent from 2020 to 2024, then 15.1 percent in 2025 and 15.3 percent in 2026 per trade coverage. The rate is higher, but the number of inspections is much lower, so HDJ treats the trend carefully.

What is a performance-based brake tester?

A performance-based brake tester measures braking force on a roller-type machine and reports braking efficiency. In 2026, 29 of 657 vehicles tested, 4.41 percent, failed the 43.5 percent minimum for combinations and were placed out of service. A truck can pass a visual check and still fail a tester.

How thick must brake linings be under federal rules?

Under 49 CFR 393.47, non-steering air drum brakes need at least 6.4 mm (1/4 inch) of lining at the shoe center, and air disc brakes need at least 3.2 mm (1/8 inch). Steering axle limits differ, and drums and rotors must meet manufacturer limits. Confirm the current text on eCFR.

How can a fleet prepare for Brake Safety Week?

Check the worst brake on every unit, not the average. Fix hoses and tubing, test air loss, measure steering axle linings, inspect rotors and drums, and keep inspection and repair records under 49 CFR 396.3. Run those checks on a schedule so any inspection week finds the same brakes.

Wrap-up

The Bottom Line

The 2026 brake safety week results show a brake system problem that has not gone away: 15.3 percent out of service, half of it from the 20 percent rule, hoses and tubing up sharply and rotors flagged on air disc brakes. Fleets should prepare for any day, not an announced week, by finding the weakest brake on each truck.

Michael Nielsen and the Heavy Duty Journal team publish brake and compliance guides at heavydutyjournal.com. The next useful step is a worst-brake-first inspection of every unit before April 18, 2027, with hoses, rotors and steering axle linings at the top of the list.

Share This Brake Safety Guide

Know a fleet manager or shop owner who wants to pass the next brake inspection? Share this guide with them.

LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Reddit Threads Email Text

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *